开发者

Why isn't UTF-8 allowed as the "ANSI" code page?

The Windows _setmbcp function allows any valid code page...

(except UTF-7 and UTF-8, which are not supported)

OK, not supporting UTF-7 m开发者_开发百科akes sense: Characters have non-unique representations and that introduces complexity and security risks.

But why not UTF-8?

As I understand it, the "ANSI" versions of the Windows API functions convert their arguments to UTF-16, call the equivalent "W" function, and convert any strings in the output to "ANSI". This is what I've been doing manually. So why can't Windows do it for me?


The "ANSI" codepage is basically legacy: Windows 9X era. All modern software should be Unicode (that is, UTF-16) based anyway.

Basically, when the Ansi code page stuff was originally designed, UTF-8 wasn't even invented and so support for multi-byte encodings was rather haphazard (i.e. most Ansi code pages are single byte, with the exception of some East Asian code pages which are one-or-two byte). Adding support for "proper" multi-byte encodings was probably deemed not worth the effort when all new development should be done in UTF-16 anyway.


_setmbcp() is a VC++ RTL function, not a Win32 API function. It only affects how the RTL interprets strings. It has no effect whatsoever on Win32 API A functions. When they call their W counterparts internally, the A functions always use MultiByteToWideChar() and WideCharToMultiByte() specifying codepage 0 (CP_ACP) to use the system default Ansi codepage for the conversions.


Michael Kaplan, an internationalization expert from Microsoft, tried to answer this on his blog.

Basically his explanation is that even though the "ANSI" versions of Windows API functions are meant to handle different code pages, historically there was an implicit expectation that character encodings would require at most two bytes per code point. UTF-8 doesn't meet that expectation, and changing all of those functions now would require a massive amount of testing.


The reason is exactly like what was said in jamesdlin's answers and the comments below it: MBCS is the same as DBCS in Windows and some functions don't work with characters that are longer than 2 bytes

Microsoft said that a UTF-8 locale might break some functions as they were written to assume multibyte encodings used no more than 2 bytes per character, thus code pages with more bytes such as UTF-8 (and also GB 18030, cp54936) could not be set as the locale.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unicode_in_Microsoft_Windows#UTF-8

So UTF-8 was allowed in functions like read/write but not when using as a locale


However Microsoft has finally fixed that so now we can use UTF-8 as a locale. In fact MS even started recommending the ANSI APIs (-A) again instead of the Unicode (-W) versions like before. There are some new options in MSVC: /execution-charset:utf-8 and /utf-8 to set the charset, or you can also set the ActiveCodePage property in appxmanifest of the UWP app

Since Windows 10 insider build 17035, before those options were introduced, a "Beta: Use Unicode UTF-8 for worldwide language support" checkbox had also been added for setting the locale code page to UTF-8

Why isn't UTF-8 allowed as the "ANSI" code page?

To open that dialog box open start menu, type "region" and select Region settings > Additional date, time & regional settings > Change date, time, or number formats > Administrative

After enabling it you can call setlocale() to change to UTF-8 locale:

Starting in Windows 10 build 17134 (April 2018 Update), the Universal C Runtime supports using a UTF-8 code page. This means that char strings passed to C runtime functions will expect strings in the UTF-8 encoding. To enable UTF-8 mode, use "UTF-8" as the code page when using setlocale. For example, setlocale(LC_ALL, ".utf8") will use the current default Windows ANSI code page (ACP) for the locale and UTF-8 for the code page.

UTF-8 Support

You can also use this in older Windows versions

To use this feature on an OS prior to Windows 10, such as Windows 7, you must use app-local deployment or link statically using version 17134 of the Windows SDK or later. For Windows 10 operating systems prior to 17134, only static linking is supported.

See also

  • Is it possible to set “locale” of a Windows application to UTF-8?
0

上一篇:

下一篇:

精彩评论

暂无评论...
验证码 换一张
取 消

最新问答

问答排行榜