开发者

Does memcpy not throw exceptions?

Hopefully there is a simple answer to this as it seems a simple question, however I have not been able to find any information on this on the interwebs.

In the following code snippet, Visual Studio complains of unreachable code at the line "delete bytes;"

try
{
   memcpy(bytes, other.bytes, count);
}
catch (...)
{
   delete[] bytes;
   throw;
}

D开发者_StackOverflow中文版oes memcpy not throw exceptions?


No. memcpy is a C function. It doesn't know about C++ features such as exceptions. (Of course, it's perfectly legal to use it in C++, although arguably not the best idea).

In response to karlphillip: I must indeed clarify my thoughts: in C++, memcpy should be used only for low-level buffer copies inside object private implementation. It shouldn't be used as mundanely as it was in C (for example to copy numbers arrays) because plain-vanilla buffers are now usually hidden inside class implementations. Classes that wrap arrays or other large amount of data (such as std::array) expose methods to manipulate their contents. And by the time I write this, Mark Ransom nicely summarized it ;-)


Your catch block catches C++ exceptions. On your platform, memcpy is not defined to throw C++ exceptions, and your compiler knows it, so it correctly informs you that your catch block will never execute.

It's allowed for memcpy to throw C++ exceptions. The function's behavior is undefined for cases when either of the pointers doesn't point at a valid object. It's perfectly valid for the function to throw a C++ exception in that situation because undefined behavior means it's perfectly valid for it to do anything.

You might find that memcpy on your platform throws OS exceptions when you're reading or writing invalid memory. You could get an access violation, but the C++ catch block doesn't catch that kind of exception. Use __try and __except for that. Better yet, analyze and edit your program to make sure you never get into such a situation in the first place. Then you don't have to worry about how any particular platform behaves.


No, memcpy does not throw exceptions.


memcpy comes from C, which predates C++ exceptions, so no. You will never catch an exception that is thrown as a result of memcpy.

0

上一篇:

下一篇:

精彩评论

暂无评论...
验证码 换一张
取 消

最新问答

问答排行榜