Passing references to Variadic templates

I'm working on an Event library and I'm facing a problem with Variadic templates.

All is working very nice except the fact that I can't pass references as parameters...

Here is a very simplified example wrote to expose my problem.

struct DelayedSignal 
{   
    ~DelayedSignal ()
    { std::cout << "~DelayedSignal CLOSE" << std::endl; }

    template<class C, class... Args>
    DelayedSignal ( void(C::*func)(Args...), C& obj )
    { std::cout << "DelayedSignal INIT - 03 - pointer to method & pointer to class instance (Arg num: " << sizeof...(Args) << ")" << std::endl; }

    template<class C, class... Args>
    DelayedSignal ( void(C::*func)(Args...), C& obj, Args... args )
    {
        std::cout << "DelayedSignal INIT - 04 - pointer to method & pointer to class instance & arguments (Arg num: " << sizeof...(Args) << ")" << std::endl;
    }
};

template<class... ArgsBis>
struct DelayedSignal_DebugHelper 
{
    ~DelayedSignal_DebugHelper ()
    { std::cout << "~DelayedSignal_DebugHelper CLOSE" << std::endl; }

    template<class C, class... Args>
    DelayedSignal_DebugHelper ( void(C::*func)(Args...), C& obj )
    { std::cout << "DelayedSignal_DebugHelper INIT - 03 - pointer to method & pointer to class instance (Arg num: " << sizeof...(Args) << ")" << std::endl; }

    template<class C, class... Args>
    DelayedSignal_DebugHelper ( void(C::*func)(Args...), C& obj, ArgsBis... args ) // Need to use ArgsBis instead of Args to make it work
    {
        std::cout << "DelayedSignal_DebugHelper INIT - 04 - pointer to method & pointer to class instance & arguments (Arg num: " << sizeof...(Args) << ")" << std::endl;
    }
};


template < class Tr, class... Args >
struct Signal
{
    void fire ( Args... args ) { std::cout << "Signal::fire::" << sizeof...(Args) << std::endl; }
};

struct Klass {};


int main()
{
    std::string str1("Blop");   // Will be used as reference
    Klass k;                    // Will be used as reference

    Signal<void, Klass&> signal_01;
    Signal<void, std::string&> signal_02;

    std::cout << "====== DelayedSignal :: needed for production purpose ===============" << std::endl;

    // OK
    DelayedSignal test01(&Signal<void, std::string&>::fire, signal_02);
    // HERE IS THE PROBLEM
    //DelayedSignal test02(&Signal<void, std::string&>::fire, signal_02, str1);

    // OK
    DelayedSignal test03(&Signal<void, Klass&>::fire, signal_01);
    // HERE IS THE PROBLEM
    //DelayedSignal test04(&Signal<void, Klass&>::fire, signal_01, k);

    std::cout << "====== DelayedSignal_DebugHelper :: used only for debug purpose ======" << std::endl;

    // OK
    DelayedSignal_DebugHelper<std::string&> test05(&Signal<void, std::string开发者_开发问答&>::fire, signal_02);
    // OK
    DelayedSignal_DebugHelper<std::string&> test06(&Signal<void, std::string&>::fire, signal_02, str1);

    // OK
    DelayedSignal_DebugHelper<Klass&> test07(&Signal<void, Klass&>::fire, signal_01);
    // OK
    DelayedSignal_DebugHelper<Klass&> test08(&Signal<void, Klass&>::fire, signal_01, k);

    return 1;
}

As I register all DelayedSignal instances into a single std::list instance I would like to avoid using template on the class itself, and that's why I use templates on the constructors instead. I could also use a pure virtual class as base for all DelayedSignal and register pointers to the virtual class into the std::list but I think it's best to minimize the use of virtual methods and I'm really intrigued by this problem...

As you can see in this example, test02 and test04 return errors if they are activated. DelayedSignal_DebugHelper is almost identical to DelayedSignal except the fact that it use ArgsBis (a class template argument) on the last constructor instead of the Args template (the method template argument), else it doesn't work (as with DelayedSignal). Args is accepted on the void(C::*func)(Args...) but is not with ArgsBis... args dispite the fact they are in the same constructor declaration.

As far as I know, there is no problem without references (DelayedSignal test04(&Signal<void, Klass>::fire, signal_01, k); for instance) or with multiple parameters (or none) as long as there is no references.

Is there anyway to fix this problem ?

Thank you.

I'm using clang which gives an absolutely fabulous error message:

test.cpp:59:19: error: no matching constructor for initialization of 'DelayedSignal'
    DelayedSignal test02(&Signal<void, std::string&>::fire, signal_02, str1);
                  ^      ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
test.cpp:9:5: note: candidate constructor template not viable: requires 2 arguments, but 3 were provided
    DelayedSignal ( void(C::*func)(Args...), C& obj )
    ^
test.cpp:13:5: note: candidate template ignored: deduced conflicting types for parameter 'Args'
      (<std::__1::basic_string<char> &> vs. <std::__1::basic_string<char>>)
    DelayedSignal ( void(C::*func)(Args...), C& obj, Args... args )
    ^

The compiler deduces conflicting types for Args:

1. std::string&
2. std::string

I believe the best way to fix this is exactly how you have done so with your DelayedSignal_DebugHelper.

Howard Hinnant is right... The other possibility you have is to use references everywhere, e.g.:

#include <iostream>

struct DelayedSignal 
{   
    ~DelayedSignal ()
     { std::cout << "~DelayedSignal CLOSE" << std::endl; }

    template<class C, class... Args>
    DelayedSignal ( void(C::*func)(Args &...), C& obj )
    { std::cout << "DelayedSignal INIT - 03 - pointer to method & pointer to class instance (Arg num: " << sizeof...(Args) << ")" << std::endl; }

    template<class C, class... Args>
    DelayedSignal ( void(C::*func)(Args &...), C& obj, Args & ... args )
    {
        std::cout << "DelayedSignal INIT - 04 - pointer to method & pointer to class instance & arguments (Arg num: " << sizeof...(Args) << ")" << std::endl;
    }
};

template < class Tr, class... Args >
struct Signal
{
     void fire ( Args &... args ) { std::cout << "Signal::fire::" << sizeof...(Args) << std::endl; }
};

struct Klass {};

int main()
{
    std::string str1("Blop");   // Will be used as reference
    Klass k;                    // Will be used as reference

    Signal<void, Klass&> signal_01;
    Signal<void, std::string&> signal_02;

    std::cout << "====== DelayedSignal :: needed for production purpose ===============" << std::endl;

    // OK
    DelayedSignal test01(&Signal<void, std::string&>::fire, signal_02);
    // HERE IS THE PROBLEM
    DelayedSignal test02(&Signal<void, std::string&>::fire, signal_02, str1);

}

As you have accepted an answer, this is just a supplementation. Though I may overlook something, identity class template like the following seems to make your code compilable.
For example:

template<class T> struct identity { typedef T type; };

struct DelayedSignal
{
    ...
    template<class C, class... Args>
    DelayedSignal ( void(C::*func)(Args...), C& obj, typename identity<Args>::type... args )
    {
       ...
    }
};

Here is a test on ideone