Best SEO method to translate a website page with google translate [closed]

Closed. This question does not meet Stack Overflow guidelines. It is not currently accepting answers.

---

This question does not appear to be about a specific programming problem, a software algorithm, or software tools primarily used by programmers. If you believe the question would be on-topic on another Stack Exchange site, you can leave a comment to explain where the question may be able to be answered.

Closed 5 years ago.

Improve this question

So must of us have a lot of content on our sites in one language or another. Since we are web professionals we spent all that time we could have been learning human languages - instead learning computer languages. So we need someway to translate our content.

Google provides a translation service (among others) and so given their massive empire I am confident that they do (or shortly will) have the best translation service. With that in mind开发者_StackOverflow社区, what is the best way to use it? We could just be lazy and use the little widget that they provide - but we would lose all the content and SEO juice because google would rewrite the links to point to "translate.googleusercontent.com?translate=...".

So my question is - how we can use this service while retaining the translated content on our site?

One method would be to use the Google AJAX API to load the content inline when the wants it. But since it is powered by JS (like jQuery)- Search Engines won't benefit from this.

Another method would be to use a server side language (like PHP) to scrap the content from the google translate page. But I'm not sure this is 100% legal.

Finally, I was wondering about using mod_rewrite to fetch the page. But again, I don't think this would benefit our site.

RewriteRule ^(.*)-fr$ http://www.google.com/translate_c?hl=fr&sl=en&u=http://site.com/$1 [R,NC]
RewriteRule ^(.*)-de$ http://www.google.com/translate_c?hl=de&sl=en&u=http://site.com/$1 [R,NC]
RewriteRule ^(.*)-es$ http://www.google.com/translate_c?hl=es&sl=en&u=http://site.com/$1 [R,NC]
RewriteRule ^(.*)-it$ http://www.google.com/translate_c?hl=it&sl=en&u=http://site.com/$1 [R,NC]

All you would need to do is add a a couple links on your pages with the variables “-fr” appended to the end of what ever URL is in the link and your set.

//View file
View Page in <a href="<?php print $uri_string; ?>-de">German</a>

Does anyone have any thoughts on this?

:EDIT:

After reading google's Terms of Service it seems that

You will not, and will not permit your end users or other third parties to: incorporate Google Results as the primary content on your Property or any page on your Property; submit any request exceeding 5000 characters in length;

Which sounds to me like you can't use the google translate URL to translate the main content - with PHP or AJAX - if that content is the main post of the page. Now how does this work? Why would you build a translation API and then not allow it to be used on the main page content?

---

Well, you should read the EULA, maybe google doesn't want you to use their service in that way.

Not to mention that Google Translate may be fine across indo-european languages, but right now, translations to other families of languages really suck, and generate comical, meaningless text (e.g. my own language, Hungarian, is a nightmare for Google). I don't think it'll advance to an at least usable level in the near future.

---

I think the most SEO friendly way to decide what language to display is to look at the Accept-Language request header, although language flag icons wouldn't be a bad idea either, in case someone using an en-us browser feels more comfortable reading French, for example.

It looks like there is an (unofficial) API for php to translate using Google translate. It appears to be unofficial, but it's hosted on Google code, so if it's something that Google didn't want, it would probably be gone by now.

You should make sure to cache the translated pages though.

http://code.google.com/p/gtranslate-api-php/

---

To have a real multilingual site, automated translations are not and will not be a good enough solution. On my site, I've added an interface allowing easy human translation and Google translate (as well as babelfish) is used for suggesting translations before a real human does the actual translations. Check the project at http://transposh.org/ is your site is on WordPress

---

The quality of SEO Translate is still questionable. Given that it is based on statistical translation, in the long run it will improve, but today it's outright dangerous. I would not use it for my site - as I pointed out in one of my last posts on my blog about the impact on the new Google algorithm on website translation, the latest Google Panda algorithm update penalizes spelling and grammar errors, so machine translation might ultimately penalize you.

---

After more research, apparently google does expose the JSON URL to make direct requests - so using a server side language does seem to be an option (as long as they are cached). However, once you get that content you still need to figure out how to allow users to access it in the flow of your current app. Perhaps something like the mod_rewrite method mentioned above?

---

You can translate text through the google language api's REST interface. Here is a PHP library that does it: http://code.google.com/p/php-language-api/

A simple example is on the project page.