开发者

Any value in JavaScript/HTML Decoupling? if so how?

Lately I've been writing more and more JavaScript for the websites I've been creating. And I can't help but think that I'm doing something wrong, or there has to be a better way.

I have a clean separation of concerns on the server side, but on the client side, I find myself having entire sections of JavaScript that are dependent on specific element id's and class names, etc. For example, on one page, that has a lot of form fields, I may have a section of code that looks like:

$(document).ready(function() {
     $("#ButtonID1").button();
     $("#Grid").someGridFunction();
     $(".data-fields").datepicker();
     $(".submit-links").click(function() { this.closest("form").submit(); });
});

What I'd almost prefer is some way for the HTML elements to request to obtain certain functionality. Something like:

<input type="text" data-make="datepicker" />

But even that is flawed, because customization of that would require more and more attributes on the HTML element to detail specifics. I had a similar setup done with KnockoutJS and I really wasn't happy with the HTML that was required.

Maybe something along the lines of this:

<input type="text" data-init="buildDefaultDatePicker" />

where "buildDefaultDatePicker" is a JavaScript function that handles the necessary work.

In the end, the question I have is two fold. Is there any value in separating the JavaScript from the UI in regards to specific element ids and class names. And if so, what patterns, and or methods have you used to achieve this?

(Note, I'm using jQuery syntax above, but I think this question is framework agnostic, so shouldn't matter for th开发者_如何学Pythone answers)


It looks to me like you've got the right idea already (using classes to apply JavaScript enhancement to specific elements). Using a custom attribute such as data-make or data-init would be just another (more fiddly) way of doing the same thing. The way you have things already, specific classes can be used as the request to obtain certain functionality.

The method I'd advise is keeping a clean separation between your HTML and JavaScript. The JavaScript should always be in external files, and written to target page elements on $(document).ready to provide the requested functionality.


I'd just use a class to signify the elements you want to attach behavior to. It has a semantic meaning, and you aren't coupling the html IDs or their locations into the javascript.

In the likely event that you need some specifics, like say a minimum or maximum date on a date picker, a light sprinkling of data attributes I think is an elegant way to provide it. But anything that would require more than a few data attributes is probably, in reality, a whole new kind of thing that deserves its own class, thus removing the need for the data attributes. For example, you might have a datepicker class, and find yourself constantly providing a minimum date of today to force a future date selection. Well, just make a 'futuredatepicker' class instead.

0

上一篇:

下一篇:

精彩评论

暂无评论...
验证码 换一张
取 消

最新问答

问答排行榜