Cucumber tests and captcha: how to handle that?

We are considering using Cucumber for testing web applications (not in rails, most of them are asp.net actually).

The applications are in production, our main goal is to test if everything is fine with the services, from time to time开发者_运维百科, infra people would run it.

We have two questions:

1) Is this a good use for cucumber? Do community people encourage this use of cucumber feature definitions?

2) We have some captchas in our applications. Is there an widely adopted solution for this common problem?

Cucumber looks relatively new. I am a Java person and have used Selenium, HtmlUnit, JWebUnit, etc. Selenium runs in .net, ruby, java, and some other scripting languages.

Selenium has been around for a while (2004 whereas Cucumber is relatively new, 2007).

Selenium has an IDE so you can easily record tests in firefox, save them, and then run them in your integration tests.

I am biased towards Selenium, but it does a good job and allows you to test your applications in several browsers (firefox, safari, IE). It also has support for distributing tests across several servers (if your environment is that large, it supports it).

Ideally, you would have developers or the infrastructure people writing the tests. Then if you have a CI server, you could automatically run the tests you have recorded/written, and then continuously check your application still works as a whole. This works really great for catching errors as soon as they happen so if the developer makes a change and breaks something out of his scope, it will be fresh in his or her head.

As far as CAPTCHA goes, there are various libraries out there. I am unfortunately more knowledgeable with the Java equivalent and not so much with the .Net. Don't write your own, there should be a library you can use.

Walter

ad 1. in my opinion cucumber is great, also we were able to convince our customers to actually understand and verify the tests we wrote in cucumber. We used cucumber + watir for webtesting

ad 2. as far as captcha goes, do you mean how to ignore the captcha for testing? we do not show captcha for our own ip addresses, you could also always accept a specific value for the captcha if the request comes from your development or test environments ip

I can recommend Cucumber. I trained a team of developers and managers to use it on my last project (a PHP application). It worked very well in most cases.

I think your two questions are mutually exclusive. Captcha is designed to prevent something automated so you're going to have to solve that problem for which ever automated test runner you use. You can probably mock something up or work out how to disable it in your test environment. I would opt for the latter. I don't imagine it would be critical to cover your captcha in your test suite.