Help with SQL Server Trigger to truncate bad data before insert

We consume a web service that decided to alter the max length of a field from 255. We have a legacy vendor table on our end that is still capped at 255. We are hoping to use a trigger to address this issue temporarily until we can implement a more business-friendly solution in our next iteration.

Here's what I started with:

CREATE TRIGGER [mySchema].[TruncDescription] 
ON  [mySchema].[myTable] 
INSTEAD OF INSERT
AS 
BEGIN
SET NOCOUNT ON;

INSERT INTO [mySchema].[myTable]
SELECT SubType, type, substring(description, 1, 255)
FROM inserted
END

However, when I try开发者_Python百科 to insert on myTable, I get the error:

String or binary data would be truncated. The statement has been terminated.

I tried experimenting with SET ANSI_WARNINGS OFF which allowed the query to work but then simply didn't insert any data into the description column.

Is there any way to use a trigger to truncate the too-long data or is there another alternative that I can use until a more eloquent solution can be designed? We are fairly limited in table modifications (i.e. we can't) because it's a vendor table, and we don't control the web service we're consuming so we can't ask them to fix it either. Any help would be appreciated.

The error cannot be avoided because the error is happening when the inserted table is populated.

From the documentation: http://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/library/ms191300.aspx

"The format of the inserted and deleted tables is the same as the format of the table on which the INSTEAD OF trigger is defined. Each column in the inserted and deleted tables maps directly to a column in the base table."

The only really "clever" idea I can think of is to take advantage of schemas and the default schema used by a login. If you can get the login that the web service is using to reference another table, you can increase the column size on that table and use the INSTEAD OF INSERT trigger to perform the INSERT into the vendor table. A variation of this is to create the table in a different database and set the default database for the web service login.

CREATE TRIGGER [myDB].[mySchema].[TruncDescription] 
ON  [myDB].[mySchema].[myTable] 
INSTEAD OF INSERT
AS 
BEGIN
SET NOCOUNT ON;

INSERT INTO [VendorDB].[VendorSchema].[VendorTable]
SELECT SubType, type, substring(description, 1, 255)
FROM inserted
END

With this setup everything works OK for me. Not to state the obvious but are you sure there is data in the description field when you are testing? It is possible they change one of the other fields you are inserting as well and maybe one of those is throwing the error?

CREATE TABLE [dbo].[DataPlay](
    [Data] [nvarchar](255) NULL
) ON [PRIMARY]
GO

and a trigger like this

Create TRIGGER updT ON  DataPlay 
Instead of Insert 
AS 
BEGIN
    SET NOCOUNT ON;     
INSERT INTO [tempdb].[dbo].[DataPlay]
           ([Data])
           (Select substring(Data, 1, 255) from inserted)
END
GO

then inserting with

Declare @d as nvarchar(max)
Select @d = REPLICATE('a', 500)
SET ANSI_WARNINGS OFF
INSERT INTO [tempdb].[dbo].[DataPlay]
           ([Data])
     VALUES
           (@d)
GO

I am unable to reproduce this issue on SQL 2008 R2 using:

Declare @table table ( fielda varchar(10) )

Insert  Into @table ( fielda )
Values  ( Substring('12345678901234567890', 1, 10) )

Please make sure that your field is really defined as varchar(255).

I also strongly suggest you use an Insert statement with an explicit field list. While your Insert is syntactically correct, you really should be using an explicit field list (like in my sample). The problem is when you don't specify a field list you are at the mercy of SQL and the table definition for the field order. When you do use a field list you can change the order of the fields in the table (or add new fields in the middle) and not care about your insert statements.